The league folded after the 1926 season due to league-jumping and barnstorming habits of many of the teams and players.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/eb0fd/eb0fd6515493e15d518bc73e6aa37c4c3e4cef7a" alt="1924-25 PBL2 Champion Philadelphia Sphas 1924-25 PBL2 Champion Philadelphia Sphas"
z: best record, c: conference winner, y: division winner, w: wildcard, x: clinched playoff spot
The 1925 Philadelphia St. Henry missed the postseason after finishing the PBL2 regular season in 2nd place with a 11-9 record.