By 1905, the exodus of pro football talent to the Ohio League, diminished the region's level of play and the national professional champions, were usually then claimed by the teams from Ohio. The WPPFC quickly faded from significance and the record books.
| TEAM | W | L | T | Pct | ||
 | Latrobe AA | 8 | 0 | 0 | 1.000 | |
 | Jeannette AC | .000 | ||||
| | McKeesport | .000 | ||||
 | Pitcairn | .000 | ||||
 | Orange AC | .000 | ||||
 | Watertown | .000 | ||||
 | Warslow AC | .000 | ||||
 | Syracuse AC | .000 |