Standings were determined by number of total wins, rather than winning percentage. Historical records of game results and player statistics may be missing or incomplete.
TEAMWLPctGB
1859 Brooklyn Excelsior LogoExcelsior 123.800-
1859 Brooklyn Atlantic LogoAtlantic   111.917-0.5
1859 Brooklyn Eckford LogoEckford 113.7860.5
1859 Brooklyn Star LogoBkn. Star 81.8891.0
1859 New York Eagle LogoEagle 63.6673.0
1859 New Brunswick Liberty LogoLiberty 51.8332.5
1859 New York Empire LogoEmpire 44.5004.5
1859 New York Gotham LogoGotham 45.4445.0
1859 New York Putnam LogoPutnam 33.5004.5
1859 New York Mutual LogoMutual 35.3755.5
1859 Buffalo Niagara LogoNiagara 201.0003.5
1859 Brooklyn Oriental LogoOriental 21.6674.0
1859 Morrisania Union LogoUnion 23.4005.0
1859 Brooklyn Pastime LogoPastime 26.2506.5
1859 New York Knickerbocker LogoKnicks 13.2505.5
1859 Brooklyn Continental LogoContinental 01.0005.0
1859 New York Harlem LogoHarlem 03.0006.0
1859 New York Baltic LogoBaltic 04.0006.5
1859 Newark Adriatics LogoNewark 00.000-