Very few records were kept in the WPPFC, so the standings and win-loss records are incomplete.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/94fae/94fae49e062ba4747d22cc226a8a1d6142984fdf" alt="1896 WPPFC Champion Allegheny Athletic Assoc. 1896 WPPFC Champion Allegheny Athletic Assoc."
z: best record, c: conference winner, y: division winner, w: wildcard, x: clinched playoff spot
The 1896 Latrobe Athletic Assoc., coached by Russell Aukerman and John Brailer, missed the postseason after finishing the WPPFC regular season