A playoff between the high-scoring first-half champion East Liverpool and the accomplished defenses of second-half champion South Side never materialized because of a dispute over referees and playoff shares, so no champion was declared.

1st Half

TEAMWLPctGB
1907 East Liverpool Potters LogoEast Liverpool 228.733-
1907 South Side Germans LogoSouth Side 1713.5675.0
1907 Greensburg Tubes LogoGreensburg 1713.5675.0
1907 Homestead Young Americans LogoHomestead  1514.5176.5
1907 Butler Buckwheats LogoButler 1119.36711.0
1907 McKeesport Majestics LogoMcKeesport 722.24114.5

2nd Half

1907 South Side Germans LogoSouth Side 163.842-
1907 East Liverpool Potters LogoEast Liverpool 127.6324.0
1907 McKeesport Majestics LogoMcKeesport 117.6114.5
1907 Butler Buckwheats LogoButler 911.4507.5
1907 Greensburg Tubes LogoGreensburg 812.4008.5
1907 Canton Athletic Club LogoCanton AC  117.05614.5