Colavito began his MLB journey with the Cleveland Indians, making his debut on September 10, 1955. He quickly became a fan favorite due to his home run-hitting prowess. In 1956, his first full season, he hit 21 home runs, showcasing his potential as a power hitter. The following year, he improved his performance, hitting 25 home runs and driving in 84 runs.
The 1958 season marked a breakout year for Colavito. He hit 41 home runs, tying him for second place in the American League, and drove in 113 runs. His performance earned him a spot on the American League All-Star team, the first of several All-Star appearances throughout his career. Colavito's ability to hit home runs consistently made him a valuable asset to the Indians.
In 1959, Colavito continued to demonstrate his power at the plate, hitting 42 home runs and leading the American League. His impressive performance included a memorable game on June 10, 1959, when he hit four home runs in a single game against the Baltimore Orioles. This feat made him one of the few players in MLB history to achieve such a milestone.
Despite his success with the Indians, Colavito was traded to the Detroit Tigers before the 1960 season in exchange for Harvey Kuenn. The trade was controversial and unpopular among Cleveland fans, as Colavito was a beloved figure in the city. Nevertheless, he continued to perform well with the Tigers, hitting 35 home runs and driving in 87 runs in his first season with the team.
Colavito spent four seasons with the Tigers, consistently hitting over 30 home runs each year. In 1961, he hit 45 home runs and had 140 RBIs, both career highs. His performance helped the Tigers remain competitive in the American League, and he was named an All-Star in three of his four seasons with the team.
In 1964, Colavito was traded to the Kansas City Athletics, where he played for one season before being traded back to the Cleveland Indians in 1965. His return to Cleveland was welcomed by fans, and he continued to be a productive player, hitting 26 home runs and driving in 108 runs in his first season back with the Indians.
Colavito's second stint with the Indians lasted two seasons, after which he was traded to the Chicago White Sox in 1967. He played one season with the White Sox before finishing his career with the Los Angeles Dodgers in 1968. Although his power numbers declined in his final seasons, Colavito remained a respected player known for his professionalism and dedication to the game.
Throughout his career, Colavito was known for his strong throwing arm, which made him an asset in the outfield. He was also recognized for his ability to hit for power, finishing his career with 374 home runs and 1,159 RBIs. Colavito's contributions to the teams he played for were significant, and he remains a beloved figure among baseball fans, particularly in Cleveland.
⚾