Mike Benjamin's journey in Major League Baseball began when he was drafted by the San Francisco Giants in the third round of the 1987 MLB Draft. Known for his defensive prowess, Benjamin primarily played as a shortstop but also demonstrated his versatility by covering other infield positions when needed. His major league debut came on July 7, 1989, with the Giants, marking the start of a career that spanned over a decade.

Benjamin's time with the Giants was characterized by his reliable glove work. While his batting average was not particularly high, his defensive skills were highly valued. He spent several seasons with the Giants, providing depth to their infield and occasionally stepping in as a starter. His ability to handle the ball with precision made him a valuable asset to the team's defensive lineup.

In 1996, Benjamin was traded to the Philadelphia Phillies. During his tenure with the Phillies, he continued to be recognized for his defensive capabilities. Although his offensive numbers remained modest, he occasionally delivered key hits, contributing to the team's efforts in tight games. His role with the Phillies was similar to his previous one, serving as a dependable infielder who could be called upon in various situations.

The next chapter of Benjamin's career unfolded when he joined the Boston Red Sox in 1997. It was with the Red Sox that he experienced one of the most memorable stretches of his career. In June 1998, Benjamin achieved a remarkable feat by collecting 14 hits over three consecutive games, tying an MLB record. This offensive outburst was a highlight in a career largely defined by defensive excellence. His performance during this period demonstrated his ability to rise to the occasion and contribute significantly when the opportunity arose.

After his stint with the Red Sox, Benjamin signed with the Pittsburgh Pirates in 1999. He played with the Pirates for several seasons, continuing to provide solid defense and occasional offensive contributions. His experience and steady presence were valuable to the Pirates' infield, and he served as a mentor to younger players on the team.

Benjamin's final season in the major leagues was with the Pirates in 2002. Over the course of his career, he played in over 800 games, recording a batting average of .229 with 24 home runs and 169 RBIs. While his offensive statistics may not have been eye-catching, his defensive skills and versatility were the hallmarks of his career.

Throughout his time in Major League Baseball, Mike Benjamin was known for his work ethic and professionalism.