In the early years with the Braves, Antonelli's potential was evident, but he struggled to find consistency. His time with the team was interrupted by military service during the Korean War, which briefly paused his baseball career. Upon returning, Antonelli's career took a significant turn when he was traded to the New York Giants in 1954. This move proved to be a turning point.
The 1954 season was a breakout year for Antonelli. He became a cornerstone of the Giants' pitching staff, leading the National League with a 2.30 ERA and winning 21 games. His performance was instrumental in helping the Giants secure the National League pennant. Antonelli's excellence continued into the World Series, where he played a crucial role in the Giants' victory over the Cleveland Indians. His efforts earned him the honor of being named an All-Star for the first time in his career.
Antonelli's success with the Giants continued throughout the mid-1950s. He was selected as an All-Star multiple times and consistently ranked among the league's top pitchers. Known for his powerful fastball and sharp curve, Antonelli was a formidable opponent on the mound. His ability to control games and keep hitters off balance made him a valuable asset to the Giants.
In 1956, Antonelli had another standout season, winning 20 games and maintaining a 2.86 ERA. His performance that year further solidified his reputation as one of the league's elite pitchers. However, as the 1950s came to a close, Antonelli's dominance began to wane. He faced challenges with injuries and a decline in performance, which affected his standing in the Giants' rotation.
In 1961, Antonelli was traded back to the Braves, who had since relocated to Milwaukee. His second stint with the Braves was short-lived, and he retired from professional baseball after the 1961 season. Over the course of his career, Antonelli amassed 126 wins, a 3.34 ERA, and 1,162 strikeouts. His achievements on the field were recognized with six All-Star selections and a World Series championship.
After retiring from baseball, Antonelli returned to Rochester, where he became a successful businessman, running a chain of tire stores. He remained connected to the sport, often participating in community events and sharing his experiences with young athletes.
⚾