Mutrie's most significant role was with the New York Metropolitans, a team he managed in the early 1880s. Under his guidance, the Metropolitans became one of the leading teams in the American Association, a major league at the time. His managerial skills were evident as he led the team to a championship in 1884, showcasing his ability to build and guide a winning team.
Following his success with the Metropolitans, Mutrie took on the role of manager for the New York Gothams, a team that would later become the New York Giants. His tenure with the Gothams began in 1885, and he was instrumental in shaping the team during its formative years. Mutrie's leadership was characterized by his innovative approach to the game and his ability to motivate players.
One of Mutrie's most enduring legacies is his role in the naming of the New York Giants. It is said that after a particularly impressive victory, Mutrie exclaimed, "My big fellows!. My giants!" The name stuck, and the team has been known as the Giants ever since. This anecdote highlights Mutrie's flair for the dramatic and his deep connection to the team.
During his time with the Giants, Mutrie managed some of the era's most talented players, including Hall of Famers like Buck Ewing and Roger Connor. His ability to manage such talent was a testament to his understanding of the game and his leadership qualities. Under Mutrie's management, the Giants won National League pennants in 1888 and 1889, further cementing his reputation as a skilled manager.
Mutrie's career in baseball was not without its challenges. The competitive nature of the sport during this period, coupled with the evolving landscape of professional baseball, required adaptability and a keen sense of strategy. Despite these challenges, Mutrie remained a respected figure in the baseball community.
After stepping down from his managerial role, Mutrie continued to be involved in baseball, albeit in a less public capacity.
⚾