Coates spent the early years of his career honing his skills in the minor leagues, where he developed a reputation for his fastball and competitive spirit. It wasn't until 1959 that he became a regular fixture in the Yankees' pitching rotation. That year, Coates showcased his abilities by posting a remarkable 6-1 record with a 2.87 ERA, helping the Yankees secure the American League pennant.
The 1960 season proved to be a breakout year for Coates. He achieved an impressive 13-3 record, leading the American League in winning percentage. His performance earned him a spot on the American League All-Star team, highlighting his growing reputation as a reliable pitcher. Coates played a crucial role in the Yankees' journey to the World Series that year, although they ultimately fell to the Pittsburgh Pirates in a dramatic seven-game series.
Coates continued to be a valuable asset for the Yankees in the following seasons. In 1961, he contributed to the Yankees' dominant season, which culminated in a World Series victory over the Cincinnati Reds. Coates appeared in relief during the series, helping to secure the championship for the Yankees. His ability to perform under pressure in high-stakes games was a testament to his skill and composure on the mound.
The 1962 season saw Coates once again playing a part in the Yankees' success. He maintained a solid presence in the pitching staff, and the team went on to win another World Series, this time against the San Francisco Giants. Coates' role in the bullpen was instrumental in the Yankees' ability to clinch the title.
In 1963, Coates' time with the Yankees came to an end when he was traded to the Washington Senators. His tenure with the Senators was brief, and he soon found himself with the Cincinnati Reds. Coates continued to pitch in the major leagues, later joining the California Angels and the Houston Astros. Although his performance varied, he remained a respected figure in the league.
Coates' major league career concluded with the California Angels in 1967. Over the course of his career, he compiled a 43-22 win-loss record, a 4.00 ERA, and 396 strikeouts. His time in baseball was marked by his contributions to one of the most storied franchises in the sport, the New York Yankees, and his participation in three World Series championships.
After retiring from professional baseball, Coates returned to his roots in Virginia, where he lived a quieter life away from the spotlight of the major leagues.
⚾