Craig McMurtry's journey in Major League Baseball began when he was drafted by the Atlanta Braves in the first round of the 1980 MLB Draft. A right-handed pitcher, McMurtry made his debut with the Braves on April 10, 1983. His rookie season was impressive, as he posted a 15-9 record with a 3.08 ERA, earning him a second-place finish in the National League Rookie of the Year voting. This strong start set high expectations for his future in the league.

Throughout his time with the Braves, McMurtry was known for his solid pitching mechanics and ability to maintain composure on the mound. However, after his standout rookie season, he faced challenges in replicating that level of performance. Over the next few years, his win-loss record fluctuated, and his ERA rose, reflecting the difficulties many pitchers face in adjusting to the evolving strategies of opposing teams.

In 1987, McMurtry was traded to the Texas Rangers, where he continued his career. His tenure with the Rangers was marked by a mix of starting and relief appearances. While he did not achieve the same level of success as in his rookie year, he remained a reliable option for the pitching staff. His adaptability allowed him to fill various roles as needed by the team.

After his stint with the Rangers, McMurtry spent some time in the minor leagues, working to refine his skills and regain his form. He later signed with the Houston Astros, where he made a brief return to the majors. Although his time with the Astros was short-lived, it demonstrated his perseverance and determination to continue competing at the highest level.

McMurtry's professional baseball career concluded with his retirement from the sport.